Miles per gallon gasoline equivalent: Difference between revisions

No edit summary
No edit summary
Line 1: Line 1:
[[category:units]]
[[category:units]]
[[Category:Done 2015-02-15]]  
[[Category:Done 2017-12-31]]  
<onlyinclude>'''Miles per gallon gasoline equivalent''' refers to the [[fuel]] [[efficiency]] of electric vehicles that compares how far a [[transportation|car]] can go with how much energy is in a gallon of gasoline.</onlyinclude> This measurement is misleading as efficiency for gasoline engines is radically different from electric motors. The measurement is an attempt to compare apples to oranges, as the challenges of fuel efficiency for a [[heat engine]]-powered car are completely different from the challenges of energy efficiency for an electric [[electric vehicle]].
<onlyinclude>'''Miles per gallon gasoline equivalent''' refers to the [[fuel]] [[efficiency]] of electric vehicles that compares how far a [[transportation|car]] can go with how much energy is in a gallon of gasoline.</onlyinclude> This measurement is misleading as efficiency for gasoline engines is radically different from electric motors. The measurement is an attempt to compare apples to oranges, as the challenges of fuel efficiency for a [[heat engine]]-powered car are completely different from the challenges of energy efficiency for an electric [[electric vehicle]].


When testing electric vehicles for fuel economy, the United States EPA uses a standard of 115,000 [[BTU]] of energy per [[gallon]] (US) of [[gasoline]], which converts to 33.7 [[kWh]].<ref>http://www.edmunds.com/fuel-economy/decoding-electric-car-mpg.html</ref>  
When testing electric vehicles for fuel economy, the United States EPA uses a standard of 115,000 [[BTU]] of energy per [[gallon]] (US) of [[gasoline]], which converts to 33.7 [[kWh]].<ref>http://www.edmunds.com/fuel-economy/decoding-electric-car-mpg.html</ref>  


<math>115,000 BTU \times \frac{1055 J}{1 BTU}\times \frac{1kWh}{3,600,000 J}= 33.7 kWh</math>
::<math>115,000 BTU \times \frac{1055 \text{ J}}{1 \text{ BTU}}\times \frac{1 \text{ kWh}}{3,600,000 \text{ J}}= 33.7\text{ kWh}</math>


This result is misleading because kWh implies [[end use energy]]. Technically, gasoline is part of end use energy (it's a [[secondary fuel]]), but gasoline's energy is measured as [[heat]] not [[work]]. This gives electric vehicles an artificially good efficiency (usually by about a factor of 3). This idea is explained in more detail on the page [[energy loss]].
This result is misleading because kWh implies [[end use energy]]. Technically, gasoline is part of end use energy (it's a [[secondary fuel]]), but gasoline's energy is measured as [[heat]] not [[work]]. This gives electric vehicles an artificially good efficiency (usually by about a factor of 3). This idea is explained in more detail on the page [[energy loss]].
Line 11: Line 11:
To get an actual number for our MPGe, someone measures how many kWh the electric vehicle uses to travel 100 miles. This is then converted to the final MPGe measurement. For example, if an electric vehicle uses 29 kWh to travel 100 miles:
To get an actual number for our MPGe, someone measures how many kWh the electric vehicle uses to travel 100 miles. This is then converted to the final MPGe measurement. For example, if an electric vehicle uses 29 kWh to travel 100 miles:


<math>\frac{100 \textrm{ miles}}{29 \textrm{ kWh}} \times \frac{33.7 kWh}{1 gallon of gasoline} = 116.2 </math> MPGe.
::<math>\frac{100 \text{ miles}}{29\text{ kWh}} \times \frac{33.7\text{ kWh}}{1\text{ gallon of gasoline}} = 116.2\text{ MPGe} </math>.


Note that this is roughly 3x a normal fuel efficiency for a car (38 mpg). That's because an [[internal combustion engine]] has waste heat that accounts for 2/3 of the energy in the car!
Note that this is roughly 3x a normal fuel efficiency for a car (38 mpg). That's because an [[internal combustion engine]] has waste heat that accounts for 2/3 of the energy in the car!

Revision as of 06:06, 10 March 2018

Miles per gallon gasoline equivalent refers to the fuel efficiency of electric vehicles that compares how far a car can go with how much energy is in a gallon of gasoline. This measurement is misleading as efficiency for gasoline engines is radically different from electric motors. The measurement is an attempt to compare apples to oranges, as the challenges of fuel efficiency for a heat engine-powered car are completely different from the challenges of energy efficiency for an electric electric vehicle.

When testing electric vehicles for fuel economy, the United States EPA uses a standard of 115,000 BTU of energy per gallon (US) of gasoline, which converts to 33.7 kWh.[1]

[math]115,000 BTU \times \frac{1055 \text{ J}}{1 \text{ BTU}}\times \frac{1 \text{ kWh}}{3,600,000 \text{ J}}= 33.7\text{ kWh}[/math]

This result is misleading because kWh implies end use energy. Technically, gasoline is part of end use energy (it's a secondary fuel), but gasoline's energy is measured as heat not work. This gives electric vehicles an artificially good efficiency (usually by about a factor of 3). This idea is explained in more detail on the page energy loss.

To get an actual number for our MPGe, someone measures how many kWh the electric vehicle uses to travel 100 miles. This is then converted to the final MPGe measurement. For example, if an electric vehicle uses 29 kWh to travel 100 miles:

[math]\frac{100 \text{ miles}}{29\text{ kWh}} \times \frac{33.7\text{ kWh}}{1\text{ gallon of gasoline}} = 116.2\text{ MPGe} [/math].

Note that this is roughly 3x a normal fuel efficiency for a car (38 mpg). That's because an internal combustion engine has waste heat that accounts for 2/3 of the energy in the car!

References